HOME

OPERATION MINCEMEAT – Mayflower Theatre until 21st November 2026

Reviewer: Pat Hayward – 17th November 2026

At last, the hit musical Operation Mincemeat has arrived at Southampton’s Mayflower Theatre. The show, billed as one of the most hyped of the century, now takes the stage at the South’s largest theatre — quite a change from its West End home, the 400-seat Fortune Theatre, and its previous venues, Riverside Studios and Southwark Playhouse. Let me tell you: size does matter. A key ingredient in this show’s success has been its intimacy.

The creators – David Cumming, Felix Hagan, Natasha Hodgson and Zoe Roberts – wrote the book, lyrics and music, taking inspiration from Ewen Montagu’s book and the 1956 film The Man Who Never Was. The story closely follows the original: a scheme to mislead Germany about the Allied invasion of Sicily. The characters are farcical interpretations of real people, and the 20 songs propel the story at a lively pace. However, apart from the opening number, “Born to Lead”, few are memorable enough to hum on the way back to the car.

By design, this is a small-scale show, with a cast of five and a four-piece band. One of its central characters is Ewen Montagu, a Naval Intelligence officer who lived on Southampton’s Townhill Park Estate – the house is now Gregg’s School – and was the grandson of the estate’s owner, Lord Swaythling. After the war, he returned to Southampton and later served as Deputy Lieutenant of the County of Southampton.

Montagu is played by Holly Sumpton, who brings her comedic experience with Mischief Theatre (Groan Ups and The Comedy About a Bank Robbery) to the role. Jamie-Rose Monk makes a strong impression as Colonel “Johnny” Bevan, who oversees the Allies’ strategic deception. Monk’s career spans both comedy and drama, with performances at the Globe and the National Theatre.

The scheme itself was conceived by Charles Cholmondeley, a flight lieutenant whose poor eyesight led to his transfer to MI5. Sean Carey plays the role, continuing a performance that has taken him from the original Hammersmith production to the West End and now this major international tour. Christian Andrews gives a nervy portrayal of Hester Leggatt, the senior secretary whose eye for detail helps make the deception convincing. Charlotte Hannah-Williams plays Jean Leslie, the young clerk who often bears the brunt of the team’s poor decisions. As you might expect, each cast member also takes on several smaller roles, in Spain, Germany and England.

Ben Stones deserves credit for the imaginative set and costumes, while Mark Henderson’s lighting makes the frequent scene changes especially effective. Several times, I found myself wondering how impressive the production would be on the stage of Mayflower Studio 1. Operation Mincemeat remains an intimate piece of musical theatre, and it is best enjoyed in a setting that suits its scale. Like Six, another show created for a 400-seat theatre, its future seems secure. With most tickets sold for each performance, I expect it will return regularly.

Operation Mincemeat plays at Mayflower Theatre until 21st November. I understand a few tickets may still be available for selected performances. If you fancy a very different night at the theatre, hurry to snap one up.

NOTE: The film “The Man Who Never Was” screens on BBC2 this Sunday (22nd).

Leave a Reply

Trending